Simulator guide

Molecular models: how do ball-and-stick and space-filling models differ?

Short answer

In a ball-and-stick model, atoms are drawn as balls and bonds as sticks, so angles are easy to see. In a space-filling model, the atoms are larger and overlap, so you see the outer shape of the molecule. The Modeling molecules simulator shows 20 compounds in these models and gives their shape, angles, bond length, and bond strength.

What is a molecular model?

Molecules cannot be seen with the naked eye, so their shapes are shown with models. School lessons use two models the most.

FeatureBall-and-stickSpace-filling
Atomsseparate ballslarge balls that overlap neighboring atoms
Bondsone stick for a single bond, two for a double bond, three for a triple bondnot visible
Angleseasy to seehard to read
Best fornumber of bonds, molecular shapeouter shape of the molecule, space it takes up

The more bonds there are between two atoms, the closer the atoms are and the stronger the bond. You can see this in three compounds with two carbon atoms:

CompoundBondLengthStrength
Ethane C2H6C–C single0.154 nm348 kJ/mol
Ethylene C2H4C=C double0.134 nm614 kJ/mol
Acetylene C2H2C≡C triple0.120 nm839 kJ/mol
Modeling molecules simulator in the Nalukh chem app: a compound list on the left, a ball-and-stick model of a hydrogen molecule in the middle, and an information panel on the right
A ball-and-stick model of a hydrogen molecule and its information.

Choose a compound and switch models

Choose a compound, switch between the two models, and see the angles and bond lengths. This simulator is part of full access. The app is free to download, and 2 chapters and 5 simulators are open without sign-up.

How do you use the simulator?

  1. Choose a compound from the list on the left. Each compound has its bond type written next to it: single, double, triple, or ionic.
  2. In Stick mode, look at the atoms and sticks. Ionic bonds are drawn with dashed lines instead of sticks, and ion charges are shown with small symbols.
  3. Press the Space-filling button. The sticks disappear, and the atoms grow and overlap each other.
  4. When you choose a compound with an angle, an Angle button appears in Stick mode. Use it to turn the angle arc on and off.
  5. Read the Bond, Shape, Angle, Bond length · strength, and Melting / boiling information on the right panel.

Tasks to try in the simulator

  • Compare CO2 and SO2. Both have three atoms. Answer: CO2 is linear, 180°. SO2 is bent, 119°, because sulfur has a lone pair of electrons.
  • Find the angles in H2O and H2S. Answer: 104.5° and 92°.
  • Compare the bond strengths of H2, O2, and N2. Answer: 436, 498, and 945 kJ/mol. These are a single, a double, and a triple bond, in that order.
  • Choose NaCl and look for a stick. Answer: There is no stick. Ions do not share electrons. They attract each other through their opposite charges, so they are joined by a dashed line.

Things to watch for when reading molecular models

  • The picture is flat. The simulator draws molecules on a flat surface, and you cannot rotate them. CH4 is drawn as a cross, but the real molecule is tetrahedral, and its angle is 109.5°, not 90°. So no angle arc is drawn for this compound, and you read the value from the panel.
  • Ionic compounds are not molecules. For NaCl, NaOH, and MgCl2, the simulator draws only the ions in one formula. In a real crystal, a very large number of ions are arranged in a lattice.
  • Atom sizes are approximate. In the simulator, hydrogen is drawn small, and the other atoms are all drawn the same size. In reality, a chlorine atom is larger than an oxygen atom.

To learn to draw dots and bonds on paper, see the Lewis dot structures guide.

Sources

Related articles

Get Nalukh chem

Free to download. Without an account, 2 units, 5 simulators and the periodic table are open.

Nalukh chemFree to download
Download